How do lead-selling sites charge plumbers?
They sell the same thing in different ways: a customer's job details, usually to more than one trade. Here is what we could check on the companies' own pages.
| Site | How you pay | Who else gets the job |
|---|---|---|
| Angi (US) | A fee per lead, which changes with the task, the customer's location and demand. Standard leads are charged whether or not you open or respond to them. | Each request is matched with no more than five pros. |
| MyBuilder (UK) | A shortlist fee each time a customer shortlists you, based on the job's likely size, value and location, shown before you express interest. Non-refundable except under MyBuilder's own policies; refunds come as account credit. | Not stated in the terms. Being shortlisted doesn't guarantee you get to quote or win the job. |
MyBuilder's details come from its tradesperson terms dated February 2024, a PDF still on its website; its other trade pages wouldn't load for us, so check that these terms are still current. We couldn't load the current trade pricing pages of Checkatrade, Bark, Rated People or Thumbtack on 14 November 2026, so we don't quote prices for them. Ask them directly, with the two questions below.
One clause in MyBuilder's terms is worth knowing. You agree not to swap contact details with a customer outside the platform, "including directing a Customer to your own website", to avoid the shortlist fee. The customer you meet there stays the platform's customer until you've paid.
Before you sign up to any lead site, ask two questions:
- How many other trades get each job? If the answer is "it depends", ask for the most.
- When am I charged? When the lead arrives, when you reply, when the customer replies, or only when you win the job.
What does a shared lead really cost you?
More than the price on the lead. The number that matters is what you spend for each job you actually win.
Here's the sum, with made-up numbers; use your own:
- A lead costs £20.
- Four other plumbers get the same job, and you win one in four of the jobs you reply to.
- So each job you win has cost £80 in leads, plus the time you spent on the three quotes that went elsewhere.
That can still be worth it for a boiler swap. For a £120 tap repair, it rarely is. And the race to reply first is hard to win when you're under a sink.
A lead from your own website or Google profile isn't free either: it costs time, and maybe a web designer. But nobody else is quoting on it, and the customer chose you.
1. Make your Google Business Profile do the work
Some people looking for a plumber never get as far as a website: they search, look at the map and call from there. That listing is your Google Business Profile, and it costs nothing.
Google says local results depend on three things: relevance (how well your profile matches the search), distance (how far you are from the person searching) and prominence (how well known you are). It also says there's no way to pay for a better local ranking. So the work is in the profile itself:
- Fill in everything: your services, the areas you cover, a description that says what you do in plain words.
- Keep your hours right, including special hours for bank holidays, and say clearly if you take emergency call-outs.
- Ask for reviews and reply to them. Google says more reviews and good ratings can help your local ranking, and that replying helps too. Ask at the end of every job, while the customer is pleased.
- Add photos of your own work: the finished bathroom, the tidy boiler cupboard, your van.
- Link to the right page. Google lets you add appointment links to your profile. Point them at your quote or call-back page, not your home page.
In some areas Google also sells Local Services Ads, where you pay for leads rather than clicks, and plumbers are one of the listed categories. Google says you only hear from customers who chose your profile. Check whether it's available where you work, and treat it like any other paid source: count the cost per job won.
2. Ask one question first: urgent or a quote?
A plumbing website gets two kinds of visitor. Someone with a burst pipe wants a plumber today. Someone planning a new bathroom wants a price and is in no hurry. If both get the same "Contact us" form, the first rings someone else and the second puts it off.
So ask before you offer anything: "How soon do you need someone?" with answers to tap, such as Right now, This week and Just planning. Then:
- Urgent: a big "Call us now" button, and WhatsApp for people who'd rather send a photo of the leak.
- Planning: "Get a quote", asking only for what you need to reply: name, phone or email, postcode and what needs doing.
We go through the two doors and the quote form in more detail in plumber website getting traffic but no calls. The point here is simpler: a lead you never get because the page offered the wrong thing costs you just as much as a lead you paid for and lost.
3. Offer a call-back for when you can't pick up
You can't answer the phone with your hands in a drain. A missed call from your website often becomes a call to the next plumber in the search results.
A call-back request fixes much of that. The visitor leaves a name, number and postcode, picks a time (as soon as possible, this afternoon, this evening), and you ring when you're free. Say on the page how fast you reply, and keep the promise: "We call back within the hour, 7am to 9pm."
Two things make a call-back work:
- The request reaches you straight away, on your phone, not in an inbox you check at night.
- It tells you enough to decide. The postcode and the problem tell you whether the job is worth the drive before you ring.
4. Note where every job came from
You can't compare your website with a lead site if you don't know where your jobs came from. Keep a simple list, a notebook or a spreadsheet, with one line per enquiry: the date, where it came from (website, Google profile, a lead site, word of mouth), whether you quoted and whether you won it.
After two or three months, you'll know your cost per job won for each source. Then you can decide with real numbers whether a lead-site subscription earns its place, or whether that money would be better spent on your own site.
Where Signal fits
Signal for local trades does points 2 and 3 on your own website. A small script reads each visit (the pages read, where the visitor came from, whether they've been before), asks a question such as "How urgent is it?" or "What's your postcode?" when the answer would change what to offer, and then offers the right next step: Call us now, WhatsApp us a photo or Call me back this afternoon. You get an email alert with the postcode and the problem when someone is ready. It never stores IP addresses.
You can try it on the demo plumber's site, and run it in shadow mode on yours first, to see what it would have done without visitors seeing anything. Plans start at €39 a month for 5,000 visitors; see pricing.
It doesn't help with your Google Business Profile, your reviews or the people who never visit your site. Those are yours to do, and they cost nothing.
When lead-selling sites are the right choice
- You're just starting out. With no reviews and a new website, your own leads will be slow for a while. A lead site can fill the diary while you build both.
- You have quiet weeks to fill. If a lead costs less than an empty day, buying a few can make sense, as long as you track what you win.
- The jobs are big. On a full bathroom or a heating system, a shared lead can still pay off even at a low win rate.
- You use the platform for trust, not leads. Some customers look for a badge or a profile on a site they know. That's a different thing to pay for, and it's worth asking whether you can buy the listing without the leads.
For the same diagnosis for any small business, see website traffic but no leads. For seasonal offers without a webshop, see Black Friday for service businesses.
Questions people ask
Is it worth buying plumbing leads? Sometimes. Work out your cost per job won, not per lead, and ask how many other trades get each job. Leads for big jobs are more likely to pay off than leads for small repairs.
How do plumbers get more customers without paying for leads? A complete Google Business Profile with steady reviews, and a website that asks whether the job is urgent, gives urgent visitors a way to call or WhatsApp now, and offers everyone else a quote or a call-back.
Can I pay Google to show my plumbing business higher on the map? Not in the normal local results: Google says there's no way to pay for a better local ranking. Ads, including Local Services Ads where available, are shown separately.